The Broadway Theatre of Pitman is proud to announce our exciting 2026 Mainstage Season, featuring six outstanding Broadway-style musicals that promise to entertain, inspire, and delight. Our new season lineup includes Merrily We Roll Along, Anastasia The Musical, A Bronx Tale, The Musical, Jimmy Buffett’s Escape to Margaritaville, The Bodyguard, The Musical, and Disney’s Freaky Friday. From timeless classics to modern hits, this season is designed to offer something for every theatre lover. Full descriptions of each show are listed on the 2026 season order form below.
As a special thank you to our loyal patrons, we’re offering an exclusive opportunity to renew your subscription before tickets go on sale to the general public. For a limited time, you can purchase all six shows for just $100—an incredible value at 50% off our standard ticket pricing. A nominal handling and tax fee of $25 will be added per subscription, making your total just $125. That’s less than $17 per show before fees, and an unbeatable price for high-quality, Broadway-caliber productions.
To guarantee your current seats, we must receive your renewal by August 15, 2025. After this date, any unrenewed seats will become available to new subscribers. Renew early to ensure you keep your preferred series and seats.
The $100 subscription offer will expire at 11:59 PM on November 1, 2025. After this deadline, the subscription price increases to $170 plus a $30 handling and tax fee. While subscriptions will still be available at that rate, we encourage early renewal to take advantage of the lower price.
All subscriptions will close at 4:00 PM on December 1, 2025. After that, individual tickets will be sold for $40 each, and season packages will no longer be available. Subscriptions provide not only the best pricing, but also the convenience of reserving your entire season in advance.
To secure your subscription, simply return the renewal form included in your mailer along with payment by the deadline. Please don’t wait until the last minute—mail early to ensure your spot in what promises to be an incredible season of theatre.
We look forward to welcoming you back for our 2026 Mainstage Season at The Broadway Theatre of Pitman.
Merrily We Roll Along
January 16, 2026 – February 8, 2026
From the creators of a landmark musical comes a thrilling, time-reversing story about friendship, ambition, and the price of success. This emotionally charged show takes you on a journey backward through the lives of three close friends—once full of hope and dreams—now facing the consequences of compromise and lost ideals. With a brilliant Broadway-style score and sharp New York wit, it’s a powerful and moving reminder of what it means to stay true to yourself in the pursuit of greatness.
Anastasia The Musical
March 6, 2026 – March 29, 2026
From the creators of beloved Broadway classics comes a dazzling musical that sweeps you from the fall of the Russian Empire to the vibrant streets of 1920s Paris. Follow a brave young woman on a thrilling journey to uncover the secrets of her past, pursued by a relentless Soviet officer. Alongside a charming con man and a lovable ex-aristocrat, she embarks on an unforgettable adventure filled with heart, hope, and the search for home and family.
A Bronx Tale, The Musical
April 24, 2026 - May 17, 2026
Step into the vibrant streets of the 1960s Bronx in this gripping musical about a young man torn between the steady guidance of his hardworking father and the alluring power of a local mob boss. With unforgettable music and heartfelt storytelling, this show explores themes of loyalty, respect, and the true meaning of family in a world where every choice counts. Raw, powerful, and unforgettable.
Jimmy Buffett’s Escape to Margaritaville
July 3, 2026 – July 26, 2026
Get ready to kick back and soak up the island vibes with a musical comedy packed full of Jimmy Buffett’s greatest hits—from “Margaritaville” to “Cheeseburger in Paradise” and more. This hilarious and heartwarming show, created by Emmy-winning writers, delivers a feel-good party full of laughter, love, and irresistible beachside fun. Perfect for anyone ready to escape and celebrate life’s good times.
THE BODYGUARD The Musical
September 4, 2026 – September 27, 2026
When a former Secret Service agent is hired to protect a superstar from a dangerous stalker, sparks fly in this thrilling and romantic musical. Packed with unforgettable hits like “I Will Always Love You” and “I Wanna Dance with Somebody,” this West End sensation delivers heart-pounding suspense, sizzling chemistry, and powerhouse vocals that will keep you on the edge of your seat—and leave you swooning.
Disney’s Freaky Friday
October 23, 2026 – November 15, 2026
When a busy mom and her teenage daughter magically swap bodies, they have just one day to set things right—but along the way, they discover what it really means to walk in each other’s shoes. Filled with humor, heart, and a fresh take on a beloved story, this new musical captures the ups and downs of family life, self-discovery, and the unbreakable bond between mother and daughter.